FiLife - Your Financial Lifeline

Your Financial LifelineTM

In partnership with The Wall Street Journal
 
 

Question

melissam
Newcomer
Votes+2
Views492

melissam asked about a year ago in 529 Plans

college savings vs retirement savings

someone told me it makes more sense to save for retirement than college because my kids can borrow for college but you can't borrow for retirement. what do you think?

Was this question interesting?

Yes

(3)

No

(1)

Permalink | Abuse

FiLife Recommends

Answer Question
  • Share:

2 Answers

Sort by:
Kelly Phillips Erb
FiLife Contributor
Reply

This is a tough question because you have to compare circumstances...
Some questions to consider:
How old are you versus how old are your children? Starting a savings plan for high school aged children might not give you the best benefit. Starting a savings plan (assuming you opt for a 529 plan) for younger children allows you to accrue more tax free or tax deferred growth.
How old are you? Do you have other savings or retirement plans? Can you count on Social Security?
Does your employer offers a matching plan for retirement contributions? If so, it might make sense to participate because you're doubling your savings.
Does your state offers a 529 plan that allows you to buy college credits at today's prices? If so, and your children are small, you may be able to offset the spiraling costs of college today.
Also consider that contributions to most retirement plans results in a tax deduction today for federal purposes while saving with a 529 plan does not (though there may be some state tax savings depending on your state).
That probably didn't give you an answer but I hope it gives you some food for thought. I recommend that you sit down with a financial planner and run some numbers - that way, you can look at your specific situation and see what works best for you.

Is this helpful?

Yes

(1)

No

(1)

Permalink | Abuse

Mark Kantrowitz
FiLife Contributor
Reply

Money is fungible (it's green no matter what you spend it on), so the general principle is to pursue a strategy that maximizes your overall return on investment. If that means investing in a college savings plan, you'll then need to spend less from current income to pay for college, freeing up money for retirement. And vice versa.

This yields a free key principles:

(1) Maximize the match. If your employer matches retirement plan contributions up to a limit, save to that limit. It's free money. Likewise, if your state allows you to deduct contributions to your college savings plan from your state income tax return, contribute up to that limit.

(2) Rank all savings vehicles and debt according to the after tax interest rate or return on investment, and direct any extra money to the highest rate. Paying off debt, after all, is like getting a tax-free return on investment equal to the interest rate. This can get tricky. For example, mortgage interest is deductible, but it only adds value to the extent that itemization is greater than the standard deduction. Student loan interest (for qualified education loans) is also deductible, but only up to $2,500 a year. However, that is an above-the-line deduction (technically, an exclusion from income), meaning that you can use it even if you stick with the standard deduction.

I discuss this in greater detail at FinAid in the section that discusses prioritizing savings.

Is this helpful?

Yes

(0)

No

(4)

Permalink | Abuse

Answer this Question

We want to get you real financial help as quickly as possible. To help us continually improve, please provide some feedback on your experience asking our experts your question:

The more information you can provide, the better answer our experts can give you. Tell us some more about your issue and we’ll try to give you a better answer.

Generic User Image

Ask a Question

140 characters

Tips

  • Be specific and clear.
  • Be courteous and thoughtful.
  • Share some details about your situation (age, relationship, etc)
Login, Join or login with   or

Ask a Question

140 characters

Personal Finance News

Receive our Personal Finance Newsletter

Stacker Poll of the Day

What age should you start your child's allowance?

Avg 8.4
 
Avg 8.4
 
533 responses

Top Members This Week

Kees deWit
Platinum

443

FiQ Points ?
Robert Schmansky, CFP®Napfa_small
Expert Partner

178

FiQ Points ?
GM
Silver

153

FiQ Points ?
JLynn
Platinum

130

FiQ Points ?

jerrylee
Gold

125

FiQ Points ?
Linda
Gold

118

FiQ Points ?
Tonka Beans, CFA
FiLife Contributor

71

FiQ Points ?
Joseph Alfonso, CFP®
Expert Partner

49

FiQ Points ?