Ask questions via Twitter. Tweet any question to @AskFiLife and we will respond with an answer. More.

FiLife - In partnership with The Wall Street Journal

Your Financial LifelineTM

In partnership with The Wall Street Journal
 
 

Disclaimer

FiLife is a great place to get your finances in shape, and the expert advice in the community can help you address specific or general problems. But very often you’ll also need one-on-one advice from a professional, especially since rules and laws maybe specific to your state or country. Remember that investments and other financial transactions come with risk, and you should consult an independent, qualified professional before making financial commitments.

Stop Showing this Message

Question

Doug
Bronze

Doug asked about a month ago in Credit Cards

Does "Opting-out" hurt your credit score, (aside from lowering your total credit limit when the credit card is cancelled)?

A message has to be sent from the consumer expressing their feelings about these huge credit rate increases.

Was this question interesting?

Yes

(0)

No

(0)

Permalink | Abuse

FiLife Recommends

Answer this Question
  • Share:
  •  

3 Answers

Sort by:
joe8
FiLifer
Reply

I'm with you Doug. I just cancelled two Citi cards today. I'm pretty ticked about it, too. I had perfect records for over 10 years on both of these cards. They were also tied to my frequent flyer account and kept miles from expiring. It's going to be a big hit on my available credit as together they represented a very large limit. I would very much like an informed answer to your question.

Is this helpful?

Yes

(3)

No

(1)

Permalink | Abuse

Doug1_1239503044_large

Doug replied about a month ago

Hi joe8.

I understand your feelings, and Citi is a strange bird, but you might be shooting yourself in the foot, as it were, since cancelling high-limit cards will lower your credit ratio and probably your credit score.

Another approach would be to keep these cards, and when you use them, always pay off any balance during the grace period. That way, Citi will never collect any interest from you, so you get back at them that way. And since you never carry a balance and you're not paying any interest anyway, it really doesn't matter how high they raise their rates.

When you cancel credit cards, it does not become permanent for 30 to 60 days, depending on the bank. In the next few days, once you cool down, you should be able to call Citi (ask for a credit supervisor, because the first bank representative you talk to won't be able to make that decision) and ask to have your cards re-instated, just say you were confused about what the new changes meant. I see no reason why they wouldn't be happy to re-instate your cards; can't hurt to ask, right? Remember, even if the first representative says, "No", just stay cordial and ask to talk to the credit supervisor or department. They have to allow you to talk to them if you ask. The reps usually don't know what they're talking about, but they all have egos, so be gentle! Good Luck!

Last edited by Doug at 2009-10-19 00:19:25
Barclay
Staff
Reply

Why not accept the credit limit increases? Wouldn't that improve your credit score, if you are careful not to use the cards and run up a balance?

Is this helpful?

Yes

(2)

No

(0)

Permalink | Abuse

Doug1_1239503044_large

Doug replied about a month ago

Thanks Barclay.

Accepting credit limit increases is fine with me; my problem is deciding whether to accept credit limit decreases (down from $10000 to $300) without cancelling the card. The $300 is such a pittaly amount that I'm not worried about it's affect on the ratio, but I'm wondering if cancelling a card, in and of itself, has some negative affect on your credit report?

David R Hanson
FiLife Contributor
Reply

Doug, you asked if "cancelling a card, in and of itself, has some negative affect on your credit report".

The short answer is, "it depends". :) Here are a couple of rules of thumb:

-Keep older cards over newer cards. Older cards help the total and average age of your credit profile, and are desirable for this reason.

-Keep higher limit cards over lower limit cards. Higher limits show others have trusted you with more credit, which is one indicator of creditworthiness. Also, higher limits will improve your "utilization" ratios, increasing your score.

-Keep "prime" cards, as opposed to subprime, secured, store, or gas cards. If you have good credit and several bank cards from the major issuers, their may be little reason to keep sub-prime or merchant-specifc cards, and cancelling those might help you in the long run. A common exception to this rule of thumb would be if the less desirable cards were easily your oldest cards.

Is this helpful?

Yes

(1)

No

(0)

Permalink | Abuse

Answer this Question

Generic User Image

Ask a Question

140 characters

Tips

  • Be specific and clear.
  • Be courteous and thoughtful.
  • Share some details about your situation (age, relationship, etc)

Login or Join

or login with

Ask a Question

140 characters

Expert Partners

Popular Keywords in Credit Cards

Stacker Poll of the Day

What age should you start your child's allowance?

Avg 8.5
 
Avg 8.5
 
248 responses