Ask questions via Twitter. Tweet any question to @AskFiLife and we will respond with an answer. More.

FiLife - In partnership with The Wall Street Journal

Your Financial LifelineTM

In partnership with The Wall Street Journal
 
 

Disclaimer

FiLife is a great place to get your finances in shape, and the expert advice in the community can help you address specific or general problems. But very often you’ll also need one-on-one advice from a professional, especially since rules and laws maybe specific to your state or country. Remember that investments and other financial transactions come with risk, and you should consult an independent, qualified professional before making financial commitments.

Stop Showing this Message

Question

Justin
FiLifer

Justin asked about a year ago in 401k Plans

Income limits and Roth contributions

I know that there is an upper limit to one's income, that, once reached, means that you can't contribute to a Roth IRA. However, I won't know exactly how much my income is until the end of the year. Assuming I am doing fantabulously well, does that mean I have to wait until the end of the year before I can know that I am eligible or not?

Was this question interesting?

Yes

(0)

No

(0)

Permalink | Abuse

FiLife Recommends

Answer this Question
  • Share:
  •  

1 Answer

Sort by:
Michael Kitces
FiLife Contributor
Reply

Ezra,
The good news is that no, you don't have to wait until the end of the year to do your Roth contribution. Congress had the foresight to realize that this might be a problem for some people, so they will allow you to unwind what turns out to be an "excess" contribution, as long as you do so by the due date of your tax return (including extensions if you file an extension).

So you can go ahead and make the contribution for 2008 now if you wish. If you sit down in the start of 2009 and find out that your income was so high that you actually weren't eligible to contribute, you can withdraw the excess from the account (be certain to inform the Roth IRA custodian that it should be classified as a withdrawal of an excess contribution).

However, there is a minor catch to this. Technically, the tax code requires that you take out your original contribution, PLUS/MINUS any attributable growth or losses on your investment. So if you put in $5,000, but your account goes down 10%, you are only supposed to take back $4,500. If you put if $5,000 and the account goes up 10%, you need to take back out $5,500. In this case, though, the IRS says that you WILL be required to pay income taxes, and possibly an "early withdrawal" 10% penalty on your extra $500 of earnings. That's not necessarily great news.

So in the end, you need to evaluate just how likely it is that your income will exceed the limits. The good news about contributing sooner is that you start getting tax-free growth sooner. The bad news about contributing sooner is that if you have to unwind your excess contribution and you have any growth, the growth must also be withdrawn and will be subject to income taxes and a potential penalty. That's a risk you'll have to evaluate for yourself, based on your own confidence about whether you'll come in within the income limits or not.

In any event, though, be certain to withdraw that excess contribution somehow if your income really does go over the limits. Otherwise, the IRS will assess a 6% "excess contributions penalty" against the ENTIRE amount of the contribution, and the penalty can continue to apply each and every year until you correct the contribution or it turns out that you were otherwise able to contribute the amount for that future year.

So in the end, I think that the early contribution is a great idea for those who are confident that they will be under the income threshold. If you think there's some risk that you'll go over, you need to weigh for yourself how dangerous it is and whether you'd like to go for earlier tax-free growth at the risk of owing taxes and penalties on your growth instead. And either way, if it turns out you DO have an excess contribution, be certain to unwind it by the deadline so you don't face any further penalties!

I hope that helps a little!

Is this helpful?

Yes

(0)

No

(0)

Permalink | Abuse

Answer this Question

Generic User Image

Ask a Question

140 characters

Tips

  • Be specific and clear.
  • Be courteous and thoughtful.
  • Share some details about your situation (age, relationship, etc)

Login or Join

or login with

Ask a Question

140 characters

Expert Partners

Popular Keywords in 401k Plans

Stacker Poll of the Day

What age should you start your child's allowance?

Avg 8.5
 
Avg 8.5
 
246 responses