question about online transfer fee between different banks

Rishabh_1227291137_large
On Nov 19, 2008 6:47 pm rishabh said:

hi. chase has been charging me an online transfer fee for monthly automatic transfers to ING. how can i get rid of this permanently? Shouldn't they be not doing this? Isn't this a rip off?

More_discussions

(6) Answers

Staff
On Nov 20, 2008 1:12 pm Ari said:

This does seem rather odd, though I am not familiar with the terms of your Chase account. I combed through both Chase checking account docs and ING Direct information and it would seem that this type of transaction should be a no-cost ACH transfer.

Is the transfer initiated by ING or Chase? Is the fee being assessed specifically to the ING transaction?

On Nov 20, 2008 3:55 pm rishabh said:

Hi.
The Chase account that I have is a basic checking account requiring me to use a debit card for 5 monthly transactions and no minimum balance requirement.

Now, i set up a monthly transfer with Chase to ING last month, and they charged me $3 online transfer fee. I don't have such auto transfers set up between any other banks, so I don't know if this particular fee is specific to ING. Now, I am contemplating whether I should cancel this monthly auto transfer.

I am not sure what an ACH transfer is.

Guru
On Nov 20, 2008 4:59 pm Dave Hanson said:

Hi rishabh,

ACH stands for "Automated Clearing House" the Federal Reserve system through which direct deposits and auto-debits pass. "Auto transfers" are simply a product name given to ACH transfers initiated by Chase.

Unfortunately, it is fairly common for banks to charge for ACH transfers FROM their accounts TO a another bank--so called ACH "pushing". On the other hand, "pulling" money is often cheaper, or even free at those same banks. So if your goal is move money from bank A to bank B, you're often better off "pulling" the money to bank B, rather than "pushing" it from bank A. So that's something to keep in mind.

Unless they have recently changed, ING doesn't charge for pushes or pulls. So one way to avoid the fee would be to cancel the auto-transfer push from Chase, and replace it with a pull from ING.

Guru
On Nov 20, 2008 10:40 pm Dave Hanson said:

Hi rishabh,

ACH stands for "Automated Clearing House" the Federal Reserve system through which direct deposits and auto-debits pass. "Auto transfers" are simply a product name given to ACH transfers initiated by Chase.

Unfortunately, it is fairly common for banks to charge for ACH transfers FROM their accounts TO a another bank--so called ACH "pushing". On the other hand, "pulling" money is often cheaper, or even free at those same banks. So if your goal is move money from bank A to bank B, you're often better off "pulling" the money to bank B, rather than "pushing" it from bank A. So that's something to keep in mind.

Unless they have recently changed, ING doesn't charge for pushes or pulls. So one way to avoid the fee would be to cancel the auto-transfer push from Chase, and replace it with a pull from ING.

On Nov 21, 2008 1:11 pm rishabh said:

Okay, great. Thanks!

Guru
On Nov 21, 2008 3:10 pm Dave Hanson said:

Hi rishabh,

ACH stands for "Automated Clearing House" the Federal Reserve system through which direct deposits and auto-debits pass. "Auto transfers" are simply a product name given to ACH transfers initiated by Chase.

Unfortunately, it is fairly common for banks to charge for ACH transfers FROM their accounts TO a another bank--so called ACH "pushing". On the other hand, "pulling" money is often cheaper, or even free at those same banks. So if your goal is move money from bank A to bank B, you're often better off "pulling" the money to bank B, rather than "pushing" it from bank A. So that's something to keep in mind.

Unless they have recently changed, ING doesn't charge for pushes or pulls. So one way to avoid the fee would be to cancel the auto-transfer push from Chase, and replace it with a pull from ING.

Answer this question

Submit

Top FiDeals

More_fideals
Sm_go
Type Today Week Ago
15 Year Fixed 4.83% Rates_down 4.99%
30 Year Fixed 5.12% Rates_down 5.18%
1 Year ARM 3.97% Rates_down 4.00%
5/1 Year ARM 4.54% Rates_up 4.53%
Type Today Week Ago
Line of Credit 4.53% Rates_down 4.65%
10 Year Loan 7.70% 7.70%
15 Year Loan 7.85% 7.85%
Type Today Week Ago
Interest Checking 0.34% 0.34%
Money Market/Savings 0.59% Rates_deposit_down 0.61%
12 Month CD 2.04% Rates_deposit_down 2.11%
60 Month IRA CD 2.95% Rates_deposit_down 3.01%
Type Today Week Ago
Cash Back Cards 10.51% Rates_down 10.72%
No Annual Fee Cards 10.95% Rates_down 11.01%
Reward Cards 11.54% Rates_down 11.65%
Small Business Cards 10.67% Rates_down 10.80%
Student Cards 13.20% Rates_down 13.45%
Platinum Cards 10.92% Rates_down 11.04%
Provided by Informa 01.07.09