FiLife - Your Financial Lifeline

Your Financial LifelineTM

In partnership with The Wall Street Journal
 
 

Question

Kristen Sullivan
FiLife Contributor
Votes0
Views5

Kristen Sullivan asked about a year ago in 401k Plans

So what do you think makes more sense - a regular 401k or a Roth 401k?

Was this question interesting?

Yes

(0)

No

(0)

Permalink | Abuse

FiLife Recommends

Answer Question
  • Share:

3 Answers

Sort by:
MoneyHoney
Bronze
Reply

Check it: http://www.filife.com/guides/all-about-401ks

I'm the sort of kid who eats their peas first, so I advise paying your taxes now and letting your savings marinate in a (f)Roth(y) 401k. But if you like to mix your flavors contribute to both a 401k and a Roth 401k. You'll have to pay taxes when you eventually draw from the regular 401k, but maybe it'll be at a lower rate in the future. ...maybe.

Is this helpful?

Yes

(1)

No

(0)

Permalink | Abuse

Hank
FiLife Contributor

Hank responded 9 months ago

Reply

It all depends on your personal tax situation. A lot of people are in a low income tax bracket while they are young (right out of college or high school) and then usually move into a higher tax bracket towards the end of their careers and in retirement. Because regular 401-k money is taxed when you withdraw it, you would then end up paying more in taxes using a traditional 401-k retirement plan rather than the Roth option in most scenarios. Roth 401-k plans are funded with money that is already been taxed, grows tax free, and capital gains and distributions are then NOT taxed in retirement. There is a distinct tax advantage to maxing out your contributions to a Roth 401-k plan first, and then investing in a traditional plan after that.

Is this helpful?

Yes

(0)

No

(0)

Permalink | Abuse

Jane M. Young, CFP, EA
FiLife Contributor
Reply

If you think you will be in the same tax bracket in retirement as you are now and you have at least 10 years before you are going to draw on the money a Roth is definitely the best way to go. There are two things that make a Roth especially appealing right now. The first is that tax rates will probably go up so you will pay even more on a traditional IRA or 401k in future. Secondly, stock market values are low so you can to buy more with your after tax dollars. Once your money is in a Roth you will not have to pay tax on the increase in value when the stock market rebounds. This should be a significant consideration.

Is this helpful?

Yes

(0)

No

(0)

Permalink | Abuse

Answer this Question

We want to get you real financial help as quickly as possible. To help us continually improve, please provide some feedback on your experience asking our experts your question:

The more information you can provide, the better answer our experts can give you. Tell us some more about your issue and we’ll try to give you a better answer.

Generic User Image

Ask a Question

140 characters

Tips

  • Be specific and clear.
  • Be courteous and thoughtful.
  • Share some details about your situation (age, relationship, etc)
Login, Join or login with   or

Ask a Question

140 characters

Personal Finance News

Receive our Personal Finance Newsletter

Stacker Poll of the Day

What age should you start your child's allowance?

Avg 8.4
 
Avg 8.4
 
538 responses

Top Members This Week

jerrylee
Gold

41

FiQ Points ?
Denise
FiLifer

27

FiQ Points ?
john
Newcomer

5

FiQ Points ?
Gabriel Young
Newcomer

4

FiQ Points ?

mrfranklin
FiLifer

3

FiQ Points ?
Fern Alix LaRocca CFP® EA
FiLife Contributor

3

FiQ Points ?
ausiman
FiLifer

2

FiQ Points ?
rashidjer
FiLifer

2

FiQ Points ?