I've had Progressive car insurance for many years and was thrilled when they began offering renters' insurance. It is underwritten by Homesite Insurance Group. I got a very reasonable rate. It was very easy to order the insurance online, and they provide lots of options so you can customize your coverage. The automatic electronic payments are very convenient, and they give you the option of paying for the whole year at once or doing installments.

took a while to answer all the questions but my roommates and i were all able to get reasonably priced renters insurance.